Oh, I wasn't suggesting that was your point! Sorry for not being clear. No, as I see it the article is a very good parody of Chomsky's style of writing/arguing when he discusses American foreign policy and particularly the Iraq War, thus I think those that wrote the article don't approve of Chomsky's position politically. I didn't read it as 'Iraq = Mordor' so much as 'let's take that git Chomsky's modus operandi and apply it to LOTR'. 'Cept I don't think Chomsky is a git. Far from it.